Alan Dershowitz Israel Self Reliance US/Israeli Relations


Sir Winston Churchill did everything in his power to convince FDR to finally engage the US in hostilities against the Third Reich, having to deal with the multi layered Democrat buffer around that president then, as Israeli PM Netanyahu now. The big difference being, while FDR was a full fledged Democrat regressive statist, he didn’t hate America, nor the UK.

Comment: Netanyahu emulates Churchill in trying to influence US policy to protect Israel


Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is acting properly in lobbying against the Iran deal.  And President Obama is acting improperly in accusing him of interfering in American foreign policy and suggesting that no other foreign leader has ever tried to do so:  “I do not recall a similar example.”

President Obama is as wrong about American history as he is about policy.  Many foreign leaders have tried to influence US foreign policy when their national interests are involved.  Lafayette tried to get the United States involved in the French Revolution, as the early colonists sought support from France in their own revolution.  Winston Churchill appeared in front of Congress and lobbied heavily to have America change its isolationist policy during the run up to the Second World War.  Nor can President Obama claim ignorance about recent events, when he himself sent David Cameron, the prime minister of the United Kingdom, to lobby Congress in favor of the Iran Deal.  Recently, Shinzo Abe, the prime minister of Japan, lobbied us with regard to the Trans-Pacific Partnership.

Prime Minister Netanyahu’s nation has a far greater stake in the Iran Deal than most of the countries that negotiated it.  But Israel was excluded from the negotiations.  Any leader of Israel would and should try to exercise whatever influence he might have in the ongoing debate over the deal.

There can be no question that Israel is the primary intended target of Iran’s quest for a nuclear arsenal.  Recall that Hashemi Rafsanjani, the former Prime Minister of Iran, has described Israel as a one bomb state that could be destroyed instantaneously, and that even if Israel retaliated, it would not destroy Iran or Islam.  No similar threats have been made against Great Britain, France, Germany, Russia or China.  Although the United States is still regarded by Iran as the “Great Satan”, it has less to fear from an Iranian nuclear arsenal than does Israel.

Does President Obama really believe that Israeli leaders are required to remain silent and simply accept the consequences of a deal that puts its population at risk?  As Prime Minister Netanyahu has repeatedly said, Israel is not Czechoslovakia, Czechoslovakia too was excluded from the negotiations that led to its dismemberment, but it had no ability to influence the policies of the negotiating nations.  Nor did it have the ability to defend itself militarily, as Israel does.

More here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.