Alan Dershowitz

MARTIN SHERMAN TO ALAN DERSHOWITZ: PUT UP OR SHUT UP…….

 

DOUBLING DOWN ON DUMB

head_in_sand

I respect Dershowitz’s public Israel advocacy, but to keep postulating the same recipes for peace already tried during prior Israeli governments, that failed, is tantamount to banging your forehead against the same wall and believing the outcome would be different. The Israeli population is not fooled anymore, they know what the Arabs leaders desire, and are not willing to give in to them anymore chances to carry out their agendas, it only results in more Israelis getting murdered.

NOTE: A debate between Sherman and Dershowitz would prove once and for all that the Left has nothing new to bring to the table except old worn out plans that have as much possibility of success now, as they did when they were first attempted.

Rebut or retract: A public challenge to Dershowitz

05/09/2013 23:14

Alan Dershowitz’s response to his derisive reception at ‘Post’ conference in New York late underscores bankruptcy of “The Case for Two States”.

Alan Dershowitz at the Jerusalem Post conference in New York, April 2013.

Alan Dershowitz at the Jerusalem Post conference in New York, April 2013. Photo: Marc Israel Sellem I have now joined this distinguished company of people who get booed for advocating territorial compromise in the interest of peace. That’s why I will no longer lend my support to ‘far-right pep’ rallies of the kind I spoke at last week.
– Alan Dershowitz, Jerusalem Post, May 5

In many ways, Alan Dershowitz’s somewhat puerile and petulant response to the derisive reception he was given by the audience at The Jerusalem Post Second Annual Conference in New York late last month vividly underscores just how bankrupt “The Case for Two States” has become.

Sulk, sulk; pout pout

True, Dershowitz has been a stout defender of Israel against its more vehement critics. For this he should be – and often is – commended.

But this does not give him a carte blanche to promote preposterous and perilous policy proposals – or immunize himself from censure when he does.

His intemperate reaction to the irreverent giggles that the plan he presented for restarting talks with the Palestinians – or at least, certain elements of the plan – elicited from the audience were hardly becoming of a figure of his stature.

Although a case could perhaps be made for greater courtesy from the crowd, Dershowitz’s disparaging dismissal of his critics as “foolish” and “part of the problem, not the solution”; and his rather juvenile jibe that he reserved the right “to tell you what I think of you, and it’s not much,” hardly added to the force of his arguments.

His conference exchange apparently stung him sufficiently to prompt him into penning a riposte last Sunday, in The Jerusalem Post, titled “Jews who boo efforts to make peace.”

In a display of pouting pique he, in essence, declared that henceforth he would confine the presentation of his blueprint for peace to more compliant and consensual crowds, sulking: “… I will no longer lend my support to ‘far-right pep’ rallies of the kind I spoke at last week.”

When an ardent and articulate two-state advocate, such as Dershowitz, finds himself resorting to insults, rather than intellect, and vows to eschew endeavors to persuade dissenting audiences of the merits of his case, the arguments for it must be becoming terribly threadbare.

Refuting straw-man claims

Read it all here.

2 Responses

  1. Two states in mandate Palestine?

    There already are two states – Jordan and Israel.

    What the Islamic front wants is the creation of another state cut from Israel. If that is granted, they will want another one cut from the remainder. Its Salami tactics – slice by slice, to cut Israel to the bone. As Israel is just 8 km wide in some regions, it will not take long to slice Israel to nothing.

  2. There’s the definition of insanity for you. Trying the same thing over and over again and expecting a different results. There’s some smart people acting mighty stupid.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *